My model is but one of many – all imperfect…
Posted in Value3 - Openness on October 20th, 2011 by Paul McArdle – Be the first to commentFive hours on a plane to and from Melbourne this week for the EUAA’s Annual Conference was a great opportunity to get most of the way through Roger Martin’s earlier book “The Opposable Mind”.
More about the book at some later stage – but just want to highlight a few quotes from the book that help to clearly explain what I mean when I say that “Openness” needs to be one of our core company values.
If there’s one overriding lesson to take away … it’s that:
(1) anything we think is real is actually (JUST) a model of reality; and
(2) that model is probably imperfect in some important respects (from p123)
If anything but your model is wrong, every other model is a problem to be eliminated or ignored. If instead your model is one of many, all of them imperfect, then the existence of a clashing version is to be expected, not feared (from p124)
My perspective is that these clashing models are to be welcomed, and even to be actively sought out, pragmatically.
‘Contented Model Defence’ is by far the most prevalent (mode of behaviour) – it is the factory setting for most people, who are generally unconscious of its operation (from p125)
In past years, I have invested considerable hours in trying to shift some employees paradigms from this ‘Contented Model Defence’ to what Roger calls a ‘Optimistic Model Seeking’ paradigm (this has been akin to seeking to facilitate the “warm–to–cold–to–hot” transition).
However our success rate has been low. I’ve recognised it far more important to ensure that anyone new on the bus shares this ‘Optimistic Model Seeking’ paradigm as a pre-requisite to coming onboard.

